Freedom The Open Source Way Contribute Articles or News to OSForgeOSForge HomeLogout from Forums
Contacting OSForgeOSForge HomeAbout OSForge
  

Root
Contribute News
Learning Corner
Linux Distributions
Linux Common FAQ's
Discussion Forums
Community Gallery
Links Directory
Search OSForge
Networking
Industry Updates
Linux & Open Source
Opinions
Press Release
Programming
Security
Web Development

White Paper
DAKCS Software Systems Introduces Innovative Customer Training Program
Zarafa and ClearCenter Announce ClearOS Integration
Zarafa Brings Browser-Based Enterprise Collaboration Client to CeBIT
Zarafa Catalyses Software Development Collaboration by Launching git.zarafa.com
Zarafa and LPI Partner on Training and Certification Program
Likewise to Grow Seattle-Area Workforce
Likewise CTO: Unleash and Secure Unstructured Data
Likewise Names Leading Open Source Voice as CTO
Launched: Zarafa Collaboration Platform 7.0 and Zarafa Archiver

View More »

SCO: Open Source undermining national security
By : Accidutzu [www] Find more article by Accidutzu on Opinion
Thursday the 22nd, January 2004 at 07:30 AM (EST)
Send this Story to a Friend Readers TalkBack (2) - 3286 Reads

Printer Friendly Page Printable format
Send this Story to a Friend Foward to Email

SCO sent a letter to Congress trying to explain why the Open Source movement is a threat to national security and information technology industry. They used the same known style: lots of claims, no proof and some lies to glue everything together.

"First, Linux and Open Source software are developed and distributed (often at no cost) under a scheme called the GNU General Public License (GPL) which, some believe, is in direct contradiction to U.S. Copyright law, to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), and to the recent Supreme Court decision in Eldred v. Ashcroft."

Replace ", some believe," with ", SCO wants you to believe," and everything is true.

The threat to the US information technology:
"Each Open Source installation displaces or pre-empts a sale of proprietary, licensable and copyright-protected software. This means fewer jobs, less software revenue and reduced incentives for software companies to innovate. Why should a software company invest and develop exciting new capabilities when their software could end up "freed" as part of Linux under the GPL?"

SCO failed to show its "freed" part and I wonder who knows the last time SCO innovated something?

"Linux software contains thousands of lines of my company's proprietary UNIX code - for which we receive no revenue. "

The revenue part is very frustrating for SCO. They still don't understand that they have to work to get some revenue.

"When I talk about this, some people think I'm an alarmist. I have a different view - I think that this may have already happened. Open Source software and the GPL, unchecked, are an easy way for our adversaries to circumvent our software export restrictions."

Caldera had been offering such code for several years but there is no mention about it in the letter.

To sum up: SCO continues to attack to raise their stock price. They use the same rhetoric and provide no evidence.

The entire letter is present here (PDF file).


  
Reader Rating from 1-5

 

Poor very 

1

2

3

4

5
 very Excellent

Talkback

Post Your Talkback | View All Talkback (2 Posted)


Posted by MaUer, The Fresh Tux
On Sunday the 25th, January 2004 at 12:31 PM (EST)
Quote | Edit | Report

Looks like $omeone bigger is supporting SCO in this issue. Why only now SCO realize that GPL treathens US software industry and country security?


Posted by Daniel, The Fresh Tux
On Monday the 26th, January 2004 at 05:26 PM (EST)
Quote | Edit | Report

"Originally posted by MaUer" Looks like $omeone bigger is supporting SCO in this issue.

Unfortunately is not only one. SCO gets a lot of money for linux license fees from Sun also. And that is a real shame. They pose as a linux champion and with the other hand they feed the enemy of linux.
Why only now SCO realize that GPL treathens US software industry and country security?

They have nothing to lose and they lie as much as they can to squize the last cent from this story.



 
Scroll Up

   About | Term of Use | Privacy | Contact us | Tell a Friend | Advertise  

OSForge News RSS Feed